It can be overwhelming to face legal issues, especially when it’s time to choose an attorney who will fit your needs. Whether you need assistance with family law, personal injury, or criminal defense, choosing the right law firm in Arizona is vital for obtaining a favorable outcome. A poorly suited lawyer can lead to a negative outcome in your case, including the possibility of prison sentences, unfavorable divorce agreements, child custody issues, financial repercussions, and more.
People often choose their legal counsel based on a quick Google search or a friend’s recommendation. These are good first steps, but they do not encompass all the measures you should take when hiring an Arizona lawyer.
The Valley Law Group is here to explain some of the factors you should review when choosing your legal representation. With our decades of combined experience and thousands of clients helped, we’ve learned the key aspects that make an attorney right for a case and what happens when the wrong choice is made.
Why Is It Important to Choose the Right Lawyer?
You may understand that it is important to choose the right lawyer, but you may not know what happens when you pick the wrong firm. The consequences can affect your case in various ways related to your situation and the field of law.
A few ways a poorly chosen attorney can affect your case include:
- Trial Avoidance – If your attorney does not have experience in litigation, they may pressure you to settle in the pre-trial phase for no justifiable reason.
- Missed Deadlines – An irresponsible legal counsel may miss deadlines that are crucial to the case, resulting in worse punishments for you because of their ineptitude.
- Confusion About the Process – Lawyers who are poor communicators can leave their clients feeling lost and confused about what’s happening.
- Quick Plea Bargain – In criminal cases, a poorly chosen attorney may take an early plea bargain despite the potential for a stronger deal. This can result in you spending more time in prison, owing larger sums, or other lingering effects on your future.
- Loss of Rights – A quick settlement in a custody battle can lead to you losing custody or visitation rights.
- Lingering Expenses – You may be required to pay higher fines, increased spousal support, or other expenses.
Once you accept a settlement or agreement, or receive a court order, undoing this final step can be challenging and expensive. The right lawyer matters because they can prevent an unfavorable outcome and save you a great deal of time, money, and stress.
Local Knowledge of Arizona Courts Is Crucial For Your Firm
Most rules and regulations in Maricopa County may be the same in other areas of the state, but a deep local knowledge can play a significant role in determining your case’s outcome. The Maricopa County Superior Court System has over one hundred commissioners and judges. Each of these professionals has their own perspective, process, and approach to the law. In truth, a divorce case under Judge Carson will not look exactly the same as one under Judge Francis.
The importance of local knowledge applies not only to court authorities but also to the prosecution you may face. An attorney who is well aware of how Maricopa County’s Attorney’s Office pursues a DUI case is prepared to build your defense against points they know the other side may make. A firm full of people who have just moved here can lead you astray, entering the courtroom at a disadvantage.
Legal teams with familiarity with how different judges and prosecutors can not only strengthen cases but also add a local advantage to negotiations. A local attorney who has a well-established rapport with the people who hold your future in their hands can do a better job of advocating for your needs. This could save you significant trouble down the road.
Knowing the individuals who make up the system is necessary, but so is a deep understanding of the requirements and rules that each courtroom prioritizes. A child custody case in Scottsdale might require a different scheduling system than one in Phoenix. Someone who understands these small idiosyncrasies can save you stress and confusion when it comes time for your hearing.
When seeking legal counsel, you’re not just hiring a lawyer; you are paying for a legal team. Prioritize an award-winning firm like The Valley Law Group, with years of experience and knowledge moving through all levels of local courts, from municipal to superior. Our skilled attorneys are prepared to provide accurate timelines, realistic expectations for your case’s outcomes, and to build a strategy that is more likely to succeed.
Trial Experience vs. “Settlement-Only” Firms in Arizona
There are many firms in Arizona that handle family, criminal, and personal injury legal matters. Some of these attorneys have a depth of trial experience that can withstand the pressures that may arise during litigation; then, there are some lawyers who are “settlement-only”. This means that they have no background in presenting a case before the courts, and more often than not, push for a pre-trial agreement.
In most cases, across all types, in Maricopa County, a settlement is reached. To illustrate, between 2022 and 2023, the county processed 406 family law cases. Of these matters, 77.6% involved a full or partial settlement before trial. Criminal cases have even higher rates – out of 2022 drug crime convictions, 99.6% were the result of a plea bargain or deal made with the court.
Knowing how to negotiate a pre-trial agreement that meets your needs is a crucial skill for a lawyer to have. However, a focus on settling can be detrimental to the discussions as well as your case. If the other parties involved know that an attorney’s firm is settlement-only, they have more leverage when approaching resolution talks.
The firm you utilize for your family law, criminal, or personal injury case should have trial experience. A lawyer who is well-known for courtroom appearances, ready for litigation, and has proven results can begin any potential negotiations from a place of strength. The other side can be more inclined to offer worthwhile deals sooner in the negotiation process that align with your needs.
The Valley Law Group has significant experience resolving cases both in and out of the courtroom right here in Maricopa County. Our founder and director of legal operations, Ryan Reppucci, earned a Litigator of the Year award in 2023 from the American Institute of Trial Lawyers. The firm you choose should have similar backgrounds and credentials that demonstrate a willingness to pursue your case in a manner best for you.
What Is the Best Way to Pick a Lawyer in Arizona?
There are many ways to pick a lawyer for your case in Arizona. Firms come in a variety of sizes, ranging from solo practitioners to massive groups with thousands of employees that operate in all states in the nation.
The following are evaluations of the three main categories of practices in Arizona:
Solo Practitioners
Solo practitioners are a prevalent type of law practice. They are led by only one attorney registered to practice in Arizona, with some hiring additional personnel for administrative purposes. A small or solo organization can provide a few benefits, such as dedication to your case, but it can also lead to issues. A few common problems include overworked employees, increased errors due to the inability to double-check matters, and a limited scope of knowledge.
Billboard Firms
Billboard firms are those well-known, mass-scale practices that can have dozens of offices and thousands of employees. They use aggressive marketing at places like bus stops, benches, commercials, and billboards. These groups tend to prioritize a high-volume approach to cases, attempting to cover as many cases as possible. This can lead to your individual interests disappearing, forgotten, as you’re simply a number in their system.
Mid-Size Teams Like The Valley Law Group
Mid-size practices like The Valley Law Group strike a balance between the two approaches, using a team large enough to collaborate on complex cases but small enough to give you the full attention you deserve. Here at TVLG, we have separate attorney groups dedicated to different branches of the law, but our teams can work together if matters overlap.
The best way to pick a lawyer is to evaluate their practice to see if they have the resources, skills, and experience necessary for your legal needs. You deserve proper support rather than being just another client or suffering delays and errors caused by an overworked attorney. You should pick your legal counsel based on how they can address your concerns, not just whether you recognize their name or whether they were the first result in a search engine query.
What Is the Most Important Value of a Lawyer?
When considering hiring assistance for a legal matter, many Arizonans wonder about the values they should look for in a lawyer. While there is no single characteristic that trumps all others, good attorneys tend to share a few common traits.
The following are a few examples you should look for in your legal representation:
- Honesty – Honesty in case expectations, billing structure, and elements of the case are vital in your legal counsel.
- Clear Communication – Your lawyer should be easy to reach and a clear communicator. The legal process can be confusing and intimidating for most people, so someone who can explain the proceedings is important.
- Preparedness – Your attorney should be prepared to complete all necessary tasks related to your case promptly. They should meet deadlines, return calls, pursue evidence, and be ready to go to trial if required.
- Experience – A lawyer that you hire should have extensive experience handling cases similar to your current situation. This not only demonstrates that they can deliver results, but it also provides them with a deeper foundation of knowledge that can only be built through practical use.
- Resilience – The legal team you choose should be resilient and eager to pursue your claim to the best of their ability. They should fight for you and never take an easy settlement as an excuse to close the case.
Our team at The Valley Law Group holds each of these values close in our practice. We are forthcoming with your chances for success and prioritize your unique needs. To do so, we communicate clearly with our clients so we can be well-prepared for whatever concerns you may have. Our lengthy experience in family, criminal, and personal injury law means we are not afraid to see your case through to the end.
These traits are evident in the overwhelmingly positive reviews we have received on Google. After 832 submissions, we have maintained a stellar 4.9-star rating for our Phoenix location. We are regularly deemed “knowledgeable and practical in [our] approach,” and clients agree that we “set forth realistic expectations.”
Questions to Ask When Evaluating an Arizona Law Firm
There are many questions you should ask when evaluating a law firm in Arizona.
Here are a few questions that can help you pick a lawyer who fits your needs:
Have You Handled Similar Cases?
This may be the most important issue to address when evaluating a lawyer. Having handled previous cases before demonstrates the type of results you can expect and a familiarity with your legal situation.
Can You Describe the Process For the Case?
Asking your potential legal counsel to explain the process not only breaks down the steps of your case, but can also tell you whether they are an open and clear communicator. They should also be able to describe the proceedings in the specific courtroom that will handle your case.
What Should I Expect?
Questions of this nature accomplish two things: the first is that the attorney can provide you with expectations for the outcomes of your case, while the second is to help you be aware of overpromising. An attorney should never make guarantees. If your potential lawyer says that the result is 100% certain, they may be overconfident in order to persuade you to trust them.
What Strategies Will You Use?
This query illuminates multiple aspects of their approach to law. It can provide an early warning sign of whether they are willing to go to trial or belong to a settlement-only firm. This question can also cover granular details, such as who you will communicate with, the parties involved in your case, and the types of evidence they may use.
One smart idea is to visit your potential legal counsel’s website and read past reviews of cases similar to yours. Then, learn more about choosing a Phoenix family attorney, and take a deeper dive into questions and issues to bring up in your initial consultation with a law firm.
Choose A Top-Rated Law Firm in Arizona for Your Legal Needs
The Valley Law Group is the right firm for your family, criminal, or personal injury case. We have deep ties to Maricopa County and can help you navigate its often-confusing and complex legal system. Our team’s size is ideal for combining a deep bank of knowledge and experience, while giving your case the attention it deserves.
The Valley Law Group takes a transparent approach to the law, being honest, diligent, and clearly communicating what you can expect when you hire us. We can represent you both in and out of the courtroom. We can then review your options with you and determine whether a trial is necessary or a threat of lengthy litigation is enough to secure the settlement you deserve.
Our skilled attorneys are prepared to advocate for your needs at each stage of your case. Someone from our team is available 24/7 for questions around your case’s process, our experience, how we can fight for you, and any other related concerns. Let us guide you through the challenges that come with a legal matter.
Don’t wait until the time for action has passed. Our team has decades of experience, knowledge, and skills that can make a positive impact in your case. Take proactive action today and contact us for a free consultation to learn how our experience in Maricopa County courts can give your case an advantage. You may also visit one of our Valley-area locations in person, in Phoenix, Gilbert, Scottsdale, or Peoria.
Sources:
- Maricopa County Superior Court. (n.d.). Judicial biographies. Retrieved October 10, 2025, from https://www.superiorcourt.maricopa.gov/JudicialBiographies/index.asp
- Arizona Criminal Justice Commission. (2023). FY2023 EDGE Report: Enforcement, Diversion, Goals, Evaluation. Retrieved October 10, 2025, from https://www.azcjc.gov/Portals/0/Documents/pubs/FY2023_EDGE_Report_Final.pdf
Jonathan Roeder, Founder/Director of Marketing of The Valley Law Group, is an Arizona native who has dedicated his life and career to the service of others. After graduating salutatorian of his high school class, Jonathan attended beautiful and prestigious Pepperdine University, where he majored in Political Science. During his tenure at Pepperdine University, his passion for helping others grew after securing a clinical position with a residential treatment center for juveniles with substance addictions. Post-graduation, Jonathan returned to Arizona and served as a residential manager for mentally and physically disabled homes.
Read More About Jonathan Roeder